Implementation research: reactive mass vaccination with single-dose oral cholera vaccine, Zambia

Objective:To describe the implementation and feasibility of an innovative mass vaccination strategy ­ based on single-dose oral cholera vaccine ­ to curb a cholera epidemic in a large urban setting.Method:In April 2016, in the early stages of a cholera outbreak in Lusaka, Zambia, the health ministry collaborated with Médecins Sans Frontières and the World Health Organization in organizing a mass vaccination campaign, based on single-dose oral cholera vaccine. Over a period of 17 days, partners mobilized 1700 health ministry staff and community volunteers for community sensitization, social mobilization and vaccination activities in 10 townships. On each day, doses of vaccine were delivered to vaccination sites and administrative coverage was estimated.Findings:Overall, vaccination teams administered 424 100 doses of vaccine to an estimated target population of 578 043, resulting in an estimated administrative coverage of 73.4%. After the campaign, few cholera cases were reported and there was no evidence of the disease spreading within the vaccinated areas. The total cost of the campaign ­ 2.31 United States dollars (US$) per dose ­ included the relatively low cost of local delivery ­ US$ 0.41 per dose.Conclusion:We found that an early and large-scale targeted reactive campaign using a single-dose oral vaccine, organized in response to a cholera epidemic within a large city, to be feasible and appeared effective. While cholera vaccines remain in short supply, the maximization of the number of vaccines in response to a cholera epidemic, by the use of just one dose per member of an at-risk community, should be considered

Inmunizaciones: [revisión] / Immunizations: [review]

Los avances en la prevención de la enfermedad diarreica aguda con el uso de vacunas orales están presentes gracias a las investigaciones en el área de los trabajos realizados en cólera, fiebre tifoidea y con más éxito en la prevención de la diarrea por rotavirus. en este consenso desarrollamos los elementos actualizados en la inmunización contra cólera, fiebre tifoidea, indicaciones y futuras vacunas. en especial, se hace referencia a la vacunación contra rotavirus, sus estudios iniciales, evaluación de la investigación en fase III (realizada en Venezuela), las características particulares de cada vacuna desarrollada y en uso hoy en día, su aplicación y seguimiento una vez iniciado el plan nacional de vacunación, finalizando con los estudios de impacto económico y costo-efectividad.

Advances in prevention of acute diarrheal disease with the use of oral vaccines have been accomplished thanks to research in cholera, typhoid fever and, with more success, in the prevention of rotavirus diarrhea. This consensus addresses updates in immunization against cholera, typhoid fever, indications and future vaccines. In particular, we refer to vaccinations against rotavirus, their initial studies, research evaluation in phase III (held in Venezuela), particular characteristics of each vaccine developed and in use today, and the follow up of its implementation once the national vaccination plan is initiated. Final considerations in relation to the economic impact and cost effectiveness studies are stated.

Use of oral cholera vaccine in complex emergencies: what next? Summary report of an expert meeting and recommendations of WHO.

Two meetings of the World Health Organization (WHO)-in 1999 and 2002-had examined the potential use of oral cholera vaccines (OCVs) as an additional public-health tool for the control of cholera. In the light of the work accomplished since 2002, WHO convened a third meeting to reexamine with a group of experts the role that OCVs might play in preventing potential outbreaks of cholera in crisis situations and to discuss the use of OCVs in endemic settings. The aim of the meeting was to agree a framework for the recommendations of WHO on these subjects and to consider the pertinence of further demonstration projects in endemic settings. The meeting addressed key issues, including currently-available vaccines, surveillance, and cholera-control measures in complex emergencies, and past experiences of using OCVs. More than 40 participants took part in the discussions, representing cholera-prone countries, humanitarian organizations, scientific institutions, United Nations agencies, and WHO. The experts agreed that when considering the use of OCVs in emergencies, a multidisciplinary approach is essential and that the prevention and control of cholera should be envisaged within the larger context of public-health priorities in times of crisis. As for the use of OCVs in endemic settings, all participants acknowledged that further data need to be collected before a clear definition of endemicity and potential vaccination strategies can be established. Results of further studies on the vaccines per se are also awaited. Recommendations relating to the use of OCVs (a) in complex emergencies and (b) in endemic settings were elaborated, and a decision-making tool for assessing the pertinence of use of OCVs in emergency settings was drafted. The document was finalized by an ad-hoc working group convened in Geneva on 1 March 2006 and is now available for field-testing. After testing, that should be carried out with the involvement of WHO and feedback from field partners, the decision-making tool will be adapted and disseminated.

Coverage and costs of mass immunization of an oral cholera vaccine in Vietnam.

The objective of this study was to describe a mass-immunization campaign of a locally-produced oral, killed whole-cell cholera vaccine in Hue city, Vietnam. Mass immunization with a 2-dose regimen of the vaccine was conducted in 13 communes in early 1998. The total, age- and sex-specific vaccine coverage was calculated using data from the vaccination records and the government census. The number of vaccine doses procured, administered, wasted, and left over, and the human and other resources required to prepare and conduct the vaccination campaign were systematically recorded. Government expenditure for planning, procurement, and delivery of the vaccine were documented. In total, 118,555 (79%) of the 49,557 targeted population were fully vaccinated during the mass-vaccination campaign. The total expenditure for the project was US dollar 105,447, resulting in a cost per fully-vaccinated person of US dollar 0.89. Mass immunization with this locally-produced oral, killed cholera vaccine was found to be feasible and affordable with attainment of high vaccination coverage.

CpG DNA, liposome and refined antigen oral cholera vaccine.

An oral cholera vaccine made up of three Vibrio cholerae antigens, i.e. lipopolysaccharide (LPS), recombinant toxin co-regulated pili (rTcpA) and heat-treated cholera toxin (H-CT) has been developed in six different formulations. Eight-week-old Wistar rats were divided into nine groups and immunized as follows: the first group received the oral vaccine 1 consisting of the three antigens (LPS, rTcpA and H-CT) associated with a liposome (L) and bacterial CpG-DNA (ODN#1826). The rats of groups 2 and 3 received oral vaccines 2 and 3 consisting of the liposome-associated three antigens with and without non-bacterial CpG-DNA (ODN#1982), respectively. Rats of groups 4 received oral vaccine 4 consisting of the three antigens mixed with the ODN#1826, similar to vaccine 1, but without liposome. Rats of groups 5 and 6 received oral vaccines 5 and 6 consisting of the three antigens with and without ODN#1982, respectively, similar to vaccines 2 and 3, but without liposome. Rats of groups 7, 8 and 9 received oral placebos, namely liposomes (L), ODN#1826 (CpG), and vaccine diluent, i.e. 5% NaHCO3 solution, respectively. All vaccines were given in three doses at 14-day intervals. It was found that the combination of liposome and ODN#1826 in vaccine 1 evoked the highest immune response to V. cholerae antigen compared to other vaccine formulations and placebos, as measured by the appearance of antigen-specific antibody-producing cells in the intestinal lamina propria. The immunogenicity according to the magnitude of the immune response was: V1>V2=V3>V4>V5=V6>V7=V8=V9. The results of this study indicate that CpG-DNA and liposome are effective mucosal adjuvants for an oral cholera vaccine prepared from refined V. cholerae antigens and their combination seems to be synergistic. The potential role of liposome as a vaccine delivery vehicle has been confirmed.

Estudio del patrón de excresión y la capacidad protectora en conejos inmunizados de forma oral con cepas atenuadas de Vibrio cholerae O1 biotipo El Tor

Con el fin de estudiar los patrones de excreción, colonización y la capacidad protectora de cepas vivas atenuadas de Vibrio cholerae O1El Tor, se inmunizaron conejos Nueva Zelandia con estas cepas y su correspondiente parental, con 2 dosis por el modelo de inoculación oral en conejos adultos. Fueron retados 2 semanas después de la segunda dosis por el modelo de intestino ligado, con cepas altamente virulentas de V. choleraeO1 serotipos Ogawa e Inaba y serogrupo O139. Se comprobó que las cepas manupuladas de forma genética no afectan los patrones de excreción, cuando se compara con su parental. Se observó en el reto una disminución en los niveles de colonización de las cepas virulentas de ambos serotipos; tanto en los conejos inmunizados con las cepas atenuadas como con la parental en comparación con animales controles inmunizados con la cepa Escherichia coli K-12, lo que indica que hubo cierto grado de protección. En el caso de los animales retados con la cepa 0139 se demostró que la protección es específica para cada serogrupo pues en este caso no se observó disminución de la colonización.

In order to study the excretion patterns, colonization and protective capacity of live sttenuated strains of Vibrio cholerae O1. E1 Tor, rabbits were immunized in New Zealand with these strains and their corresponding parental strains. 2 doses were administered by the model of oral inoculation in adult rabbits. Rabbits were rotated 2 weeks after the second dose by the model of ligated intestine with highly virulent strains of V. cholerae O1 Ogawa and Inaba serotypes and O139 serogroup. It was proved that the genetically manipulated strains do not effect the excretion patterns when they are compared with their parental strains. It was observed in the challenge a decrease in the levels of colonization of virulent strains of both serotypes, not only among the rabbits immunized with the attenuated strains, but also among those immunizedwith the parental strains in comparison with control animals immunized with the strain of Escherichia coli K-12, which means that there was certain degree of protection. In the case of the animals challenged with the O139 strain it was demonstrated that the protection is specific for each serogroup, since in this case there was no reduction of the colonization.

Pasteur oral cholera vaccine: studies of reactogenicity, clinical acceptability and immunogenicity in human volunteers.

Pasteur cholera vaccine consists of isolated antigenic fractions from V. cholerae El Tor Ogawa and Inaba. Enteric coated microgranules were prepared from antigen lyophilisate. Three doses of this vaccine were administered orally to 19 healthy young Thai adults at one week intervals. None of the volunteers experienced untowards reactions. The vibriocidal antibody responses manifested a significant antibody rise (> or = 4 fold) to serovar Inaba in 8 vaccinees (42.1%) and Ogawa in 4 (21.1%). Five and 6 vaccinees (26.3% and 31.6%) showed a > or = 4 fold rise of IgG and IgA anti-LPS, respectively.

Vacunas contra el cólera / Vaccines against cholera

El cólera es una enfermedad aguda e infecciosa que fue descrita antes de la época de Hipócrates en el siglo V AC. Se describieron varias epidemias de esta enfermedad en Asia entre los siglos XV y XVIII. A mediados del siglo XIX John Snow en Inglaterra fue el primero en describir las medidas de prevención de la enfermedad a raíz de una epidemia ocurrida en Londres. En 1883, Robert Koch realizó el descubrimiento del agente causal, Vibrio cholerae, un bacilo curvo de gran movilidad. Durante los siglos XIX y XX han ocurrido siete pandemias de cólera; en la actualidad ocurre la transmisión de la séptima. El cólera es una de las causas más importantes de morbilidad y mortalidad de algunos países de Asia y Africa y desde 1991 también en Latinoamérica. Desde principios del siglo se ha empleado una vacuna parenteral elaborada con una cepa de V. cholerae 01, inactivada con calor, la cual únicamente induce 50 por ciento de protección en jóvenes y adultos, durante un período de aproximadamente 6 meses. El empleo de adyuvantes no ha tenido influencia en su eficiencia, sino por el contrario incrementa las reacciones colaterales. Las perspectivas para el desarrollo de una vacuna eficaz contra el cólera se basan en el hecho de que más del 90 por ciento de los sujetos infectados en forma natural quedan protegidos para una segunda reinfección. El avance del desarrollo de las vacunas del cólera se ha podido efectuar gracias a un mejor conocimiento de los mecanismos de patogenicidad y antigenicidad del agente etiológico, aunque persisten incógnitas importantes. La vacuna ideal contra el cólera debería ser tan eficaz como la infección natural, sin riesgo de causar enfermedad infecciosa, de fácil administración, de bajo costo, de una sola dosis, inocua, que proteja contra la infección y obviamente contra la enfermedad grave, con protección de larga duración y probablemente de administración oral

Immunogenicity of liposome-associated oral cholera vaccine prepared from combined Vibrio cholerae antigens.

Liposomes were prepared from bovine brain sphingomyelin and cholesterol. They were reinforced by incorporation of osmium tetroxide to prevent their immediate degradation inside the host. Combined Vibrio cholerae antigens (lipopolysaccharide, crude cell-bound hemagglutinin and procholeragenoid) were orally administered to experimental rats either as free or liposome-associated. A total of 70 experimental rats was utilized in experiments comparing the immune responses of rats to liposome-associated vaccine, free vaccine, liposomes, or placebo, and to vaccines where the lipid or antigen levels were reduced. Immediately after feeding with sodium bicarbonate to lower the gastric acidity, they were fed either cholera vaccines or placebo. Results from serum ELISA revealed that the liposomes localized the immune response to the intestinal mucosa. They displayed an adjuvant property in terms of evoking a higher immune response to V. cholerae antigens, as measured by the appearance of specific antibody-producing cells in the intestinal mucosa, than when the antigens were fed alone. The adjuvanticity was found to be lipid dose dependent. Liposomes prepared with high lipid content enhanced immunogenicity of the admixture antigens to a greater degree.

Immune responses following killed whole vibrio-B subunit oral cholera vaccine in human volunteers.

Immunogenicity of killed whole vibrio and B subunit oral cholera vaccines in American and Thai volunteers were analysed in terms of significant rise of antibody titre. Three doses of 2 x 10(11) killed vibrios and 5 mg of cholera toxin B subunit were given at two-week intervals. There were no differences in the percent of volunteers with significant rise of serum immunoglobulin G and secretory immunoglobulin A (sIgA) to cholera toxin. However, the percent with significant rises of serum antibody to whole cell V. cholerae Inaba measured by vibriocidal titre and serum immunoglobulin G, and secretory immunoglobulin A to lipopolysaccharide (LPS) measured by ELISA in American volunteers were significantly different from those in Thai volunteers (89% VS 45%, 68% VS 9% and 53% VS 0%, respectively) (p less than 0.05).

The current status of cholera vaccine development and experience with cholera vaccine trials in volunteers.

In recent years notable advances have been made in the development of improved vaccines to prevent cholera. These new vaccines are administered orally to maximally stimulate intestinal secretory immunity. Killed vibrios, given in conjunction with purified B subunit or administered alone, in three spaced doses, caused no adverse reactions and have conferred significant protection in volunteer challenge studies and in field trials. Two attenuated mutants of V. cholerae, prepared by recombinant DNA techniques, CVD 103 and CVD 103-HgR are well-tolerated and elicit prominent immune responses and protective immunity after ingestion of a single oral dose. Other modern approaches being pursued include the development of auxotrophic strains and of modifying attenuated S. typhi strain Ty21a to express V. cholerae Inaba and Ogawa LPS antigens.